Monday, November 5, 2007

Hindus and Atheism

Patrix got me thinking this morning when I read this post on his blog. Rather than take up his comment space, as I will probably end up being verbose and not clear at all, I thought I will express the thoughts that came flooding into my head here. The question that started this flood of thoughts was “Are Hindus more likely to be Atheists?” And the first sound in my head is a resounding and joyous “YES”! Now why is that? Let me try and explain.

First, some caveats. This is a theoretical physicist’s answer in the sense that it is correct in the context of the ideal system and may not be valid in the more complex real world. The reason I need this “ideal system” assumption is that Hinduism is really a social construct rather than a religion. And the society is complicated. The simplifying assumption I am making here is that I am visualizing a Hindu society where there is no caste. Caste is just a designation of your profession and comes with no associated mental stigma or physical discrimination.

Given all that, why do I think Hindus are more likely to become atheist? To understand this, I need to first say what an atheist is. Conventionally, an atheist is thought to be a person who says “there is no god”. This is not quite right in my mind. It should really be a person that says “I have no god”, in exactly the same tone of voice as one would say “I have no washing machine”. Hinduism has this freedom inherently built in. In the Hindu environment, gods come in all colors and flavors. There is the “goody-goody” Rama, there is the incorrigible flirt and master of cunning, Krishna, the manifestation of wrath and lust, Shiva and so on and so forth. This allows a mindset that necessarily separates the “religious” aspects as those associated with fables and the “social” aspect that is associated with conformity, morals ethics and so on. And the “spiritual” aspect of this religion is inherently personal, in that, rightly, there is no given path, there are guidelines to choose possible paths but that is it. All this makes it an easy step up to do away with the religious aspect altogether in our minds. Thank God for the absence of “Jesus this and Jesus that” to quote lieutenant Dan from Forrest Gump!

Do you think you agree?

6 comments:

Born a Libran said...

Well, in my limited experience, I do agree with the final conclusion - that Hindus are more likely to be atheists than the other major religions (Islam and Christianity). But I dont know whether the assumptions leading to the said conclusion are all together correct. It maybe because of the more open nature of our religion. Even though there are institutions (for want of a better word) like ISKCON and stuff, Hinduism is not about spreading the religion. It is more about gaining an understanding of God by yourself (except for the emotional blackmail that mothers use so well in India). The person is left by him/herself to discover God and hence is left to understand whatever God means to the person's life - which can quite often be atheism. On the other hand, Christianity and Islam are about spreading the religion and quite often, it starts at home. So the kids are brain washed(?) pretty early in to believing in God. Not that this doesnt happen with Hinduism but it happens to a far lesser degree.

CuriousCat said...

BaL you are so right...Proselytism or equivalently the absense of it, is an important ingredient that leads to the necessary "individualism" of the spriritual path...and mother's blackmail has more to do with "morals" than anything else no?

CuriousCat said...

BTW...ISKON is Christianity of Hinduis m type thing...

tangled said...

Oh, oh, oh!
I agree with this post entirely, entirely!
I like the washing machine analogy. :)

CuriousCat said...

Thanks tangled...what's up with all the introspective negativism at some yells? Bad week?

tangled said...

The last straw of a week, rather...